Criminal Appeals

Criminal Appeals In Colorado

Criminal appeals in Colorado involve a process where a party who is dissatisfied with a decision made in a criminal trial court seeks to have that decision reviewed by a higher court. This process is governed by specific rules and procedures, and it’s important to understand its key aspects, including who can appeal, the grounds for appeal, the process, and potential outcomes.

Who Can Appeal

In Colorado, typically, it’s the defendant who files an appeal in a criminal case. The defendant may seek to overturn a conviction or the sentence imposed by the trial court. It’s important to note that the prosecution generally cannot appeal an acquittal due to the Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. However, the prosecution can appeal certain pre-trial and post-trial rulings.

Grounds for Appeal

An appeal is not a re-trial of the case. Instead, it’s a legal process to review whether the trial court made errors that significantly affected the outcome of the case. Common grounds for appeal in Colorado include:

  • Legal Errors: These include errors in the application of the law, such as incorrect jury instructions or admission of inadmissible evidence.
  • Insufficient Evidence: The defendant may argue that the evidence presented at trial was insufficient to justify the verdict.
  • Prosecutorial Misconduct: This involves inappropriate behavior by the prosecutor, like making prejudicial statements.
  • Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: The defendant may claim that their defense attorney’s performance was so poor that it violated their right to a fair trial.

The Criminal Appeals Process

The criminal appeals process typically involves several steps:

  • Notice of Appeal: The defendant must file a notice of appeal with the trial court shortly after the conviction or sentencing.
  • Record on Appeal: The trial court’s record, including transcripts of the trial and all documents filed, is prepared for the appellate court.
  • Briefs: The appellant (the party appealing) submits a brief outlining their arguments and legal grounds for the appeal. The appellee (usually the state) then submits a response brief.
  • Oral Arguments: In some cases, the appellate court may hear oral arguments from both sides.
  • Decision: The appellate court will issue a written decision. The court may affirm the trial court’s decision, reverse it, or remand the case back to the trial court for further proceedings.

Potential Outcomes

The outcomes of an appeal can vary:

  • Affirmation: The appellate court agrees with the trial court and upholds the original decision.
  • Reversal: The appellate court disagrees with the trial court and overturns the decision, possibly resulting in a dismissal of charges or acquittal.
  • Remand: The case is sent back to the trial court for further proceedings, which may involve a new trial.

Colorado Court System for Criminal Appeals

In Colorado, the initial appeal is typically made to the Colorado Court of Appeals. The Colorado Supreme Court is the highest appellate court in the state, and it reviews decisions made by the Colorado Court of Appeals. However, not all cases are eligible for review by the Supreme Court.

Criminal Appeals Is An Important Part Of Our Judicial System

The criminal appeals process in Colorado is a critical component of the judicial system, offering a means to ensure justice and the correct application of law. It’s a complex process that requires a finding an attorney with a thorough understanding of legal principles and procedural rules.

Parties involved in criminal appeals often seek the assistance of attorneys who specialize in appellate practice, as the success of an appeal can heavily depend on the quality of legal arguments and understanding of appellate law.

{I had some very serious charges and needed the best representation I could find. Shimon was honest and confident and eased my nerves from the very first meeting. My case ended up being dismissed at arraignment, which Shimon knew beforehand because he was in contact with the DAs. He still showed up in court for my hearing and helped me seal the records. I definitely recommend Shimon to anyone in a legal predicament. I know that if my case had not been dismissed, I would have been glad to have chosen Mr. Kohn.

Krista Barthel

{I cannot say enough amazing, genuine and well deserved comments about Shimon and his staff at his office. I used his expertise for myself in a criminal case and cannot be more happier about the outcome. My husband and I both had again hired Shimon & Shawn. When you hire The Kohn Law Firm, they really truly work for you. It does not matter what day or time it is, Shimon gets back to you. I had several questions, and worries that were calmed on a simple phone call with beautiful Mia, who is so pleasant to talk with, Shawn who is a great fit there and working with the best, or Shimon. He did not at one time leave out any detail of all options that were at hand. He handled all aspects of my criminal case professionally and thoroughly. He has a calming demeanor to assure you that he understands what is at stake and works to the fullest ability for the absolute best outcome! I would most definitely call him for a 3rd time!

Heather Ellenbecker

{I've worked with Shimon on various cases professionally over the last 8 years. Shimon's knowledge of the law and professional demeanor and aggressive and effective defense of his clients set him apart from all of the other attorneys I have worked with over the years. He is smart, compassionate, and tenacious. I would highly recommend him and his services.

Lisa White

{Shimon enabled me to find a path for recovery from addiction and the recovery of my life as I now know it. I gave him as many reasons as possible to give up on me and he continued to fight. I owe a great deal of gratitude to Shimon as an attorney and as a human being, he is compassionate, professional and as real as they come in the legal system. I stood to lose my life as a habitual criminal and I trusted Shimon as to what I should do and he helped lead me out of one of the darkest times of my life. I was facing 32 mandatory years for drugs and Shimon negotiated me down to 6 years probation and treatment that has changed my life. I would insist anyone who needs to hire an attorney, this is the only man I would ever recommend. Thank you Shimon.

sam burke

{Shimon is a top defense attorney who gets the job done. He stays loyal to his clients and is always there when needed. He is the best attorney I have known. Very thorough. Mr. Kohn also isn’t afraid to stand up to the prosecuting side and go after what is right.


Shimon Kohn is the attorney to call when you need the best criminal defense lawyer. I will never have enough words to express my gratitude to him for how he helped my family. He was available to answer questions honestly and reassuringly within a reasonable timeframe.
He exeplified professionalism, compassion and expertise. His professional and personal relationship with the district attorney's office is unparalleled in this community. Shimon is definitely to whom I will refer anyone and everyone who requires legal services.


{It is difficult to find truly ethical people who care in this money driven industry. Shimon handled my case quickly and ethically and was able to work within the confusing legal system to get the desired and justified outcome. I would highly recommend Mr Kohn to anyone who needs a strong legal defense and wise counsel. He not only laid out the details of my case well, he took the time to sit with me and explain when his services would NOT be useful. He was an ally in the courtroom and been a great resource outside the courtroom. Donny C.

Donny C.

{Shimon was assigned to my cases when there were many conflicts. He became the gateway to being heard on my case. Of course I had guilt to some degree, but Shimon stood up & fought for reasonable consequence. He was thorough with organization, facts, and persistent with the DA. The respect I was given during my time of incarceration to assure I wasn’t left in the dark, is absolutely the best I’d experienced. I have, and will always recommend Shimon & his law firm for their accountability, their desire to make you feel like you’re heard/personable, attention to detail and respectable reputation! What is right is right and what is wrong is wrong, but the fairness and overall justice with Kohn Law Firm is highly recommended!

Courtney Goode

Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Julian was a pleasure to meet, and work with.  What initially drew me to his counsel was his enthusiasm at working with my case, comprehensively,  and with my best interests not only in mind, but in heart as well. Like many, my financial situation was greatly impacted during 2020, and they were willing to set up amicable payment options that catered well to my specific needs at the time, which greatly helped. I would strongly recommend of course Julian,  as well as the firm as a whole,  as my experience was highly professional,  and thorough.

Roger Stacy

Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
We heard from Shimon through a family member and decided to go with him for our case which was a felony. He gave it to me straight and never promised a deal. the DA was being very agressive and wouldn’t lower the charges but nonetheless Shimon kept the pressure on them and we got the case dismissed! Obviously it’s not a guarantee he can do the same for anyone else but let me tell you this is the best lawyer in the springs he will fight tooth and nail and not try to feed you BS. I do not wish to ever have any more legal trouble but if we ever do find ourselves in a bind Shimon is the only lawyer we will ever need. I would highly suggest to anyone else if you want to sleep well at night hire this man! Thanks Shimon! You are definitely worth every penny!

Karina Gutierrez Ramos


Contact Us Now!

best colorado springs criminal attorney

“Julian Rosielle Went above and beyond for my case!! Anyone would be lucky to have him for legal representation, this man is a fighter! Thank you so much you saved my future and my career” – Robert Sanhueza