How Lawyers Can Get Legal Cases Dismissed

Get Legal Cases Dismissed – Options But No Guarantees

Getting legal cases dismissed is loosely defined as the termination of the case before a verdict is rendered. The process to get legal cases dismissed can occur for a variety of reasons and at different stages of the legal process. Below are some strategies and grounds that lawyers may utilize to seek a case dismissal:

Lack of Jurisdiction

A fundamental legal principle is that a court must have jurisdiction over the subject matter of the case and the parties involved. If a court lacks jurisdiction, a lawyer can move for dismissal.

Improper Service of Process

In civil cases, defendants must be properly served with legal papers, including a summons and a copy of the complaint. Failure to properly serve these papers provides grounds for dismissal.

Failure to State a Claim

In both criminal and civil cases, the complaint or indictment must articulate a valid claim for relief or charge. If it fails to do so, a motion to dismiss can be filed.

Insufficient Evidence

In criminal cases, if the prosecution cannot provide enough evidence to meet the burden of proof, a motion for dismissal may be granted. In some jurisdictions, this is often referred to as a “motion for a directed verdict.”

Statute of Limitations

Claims must be filed within a certain time frame as dictated by the statute of limitations. If this period has expired, a lawyer can move for the case to be dismissed.

Violation of the Right to a Speedy Trial

In criminal cases, the accused has a constitutional right to a speedy trial. If there is an unreasonable delay that is not justified or excused, a motion to dismiss may be filed.

Double Jeopardy

In criminal law, the principle of double jeopardy prevents an individual from being tried twice for the same crime in the same jurisdiction. If a case is erroneously filed in violation of this principle, it may be dismissed.

Plea Agreements

In some cases, especially criminal ones, a case might be dismissed as part of a plea bargain arrangement where the defendant agrees to plead guilty to a lesser charge.

Abuse of Process or Malicious Prosecution

If it’s evident that the legal process is being misused—for example, if someone is using the courts as a means of harassing the defendant—a motion for dismissal may be successful.

Pretrial Motions

Lawyers often file pretrial motions to challenge the admissibility of evidence, the sufficiency of the complaint or indictment, or other procedural matters. Winning one of these motions can sometimes result in the dismissal of the case.

Alternative Dispute Resolution

In civil cases, parties may agree to resolve their disputes through mediation or arbitration, resulting in the voluntary dismissal of the case.

Prosecutorial Discretion

In criminal cases, the prosecutor may choose to voluntarily dismiss charges, often due to a lack of evidence, the availability of more serious charges, or considerations related to the public interest.

It Is Possible To Get Legal Cases Dismissed

Legal professionals should conduct a thorough review of the facts, law, and procedural history of the case to determine the most effective strategy for seeking a dismissal. It is also crucial to comply with all procedural requirements and deadlines when filing motions for dismissal. Courts generally require that these motions be filed in a timely manner and be supported by appropriate legal arguments and evidence.

Note that laws and court rules can vary by jurisdiction, and the above strategies may not be applicable in all situations. Therefore, consulting with legal counsel for the most accurate and personalized advice is highly recommended.

What Our Clients Say…